Module 1 Reflections

Do I need to be physically present to build meaningful relationships with other humans? Rick raised a variant of this question in his digitally mediated presentation titled "Community is Not Virtual."   This question is one that has been so important and complicated to me in my role as a parent, especially as one who has practiced attachment parenting, full-time caregiving, co-sleeping, and extended breastfeeding with my two biological children in their early years of life. There is a strong "yes" to that question that comes along with my appreciation for our physicality, our need for touch, and the bio-chemical attributes of love that happens among embodied creatures, especially in our first years of neurological development and interpersonal bonding.   It is also a meaningful question in my spiritual journey, as I increasingly appreciate the With component of the one called God With Us as a very physical, physiological and embodied presence among humanity.  There is something so innately necessary about having unmediated access to other human bodies to feel fully part of a community and to fully have joy in inhabiting our own bodies.  I have often reflected on the word "company" which is etymogically linked to the sharing (com) of bread (pane), which is very hard to do if our presence with each other reliant upon a tool that mediates between our separation of time or place.  "Companions," then, might only be the people that we could touch and eat the same loaf of bread with, at the same time, in the same space.

But yet, C.S. Lewis has this quote attributed to him: "We read to know we are not alone."  My sense of belonging in this world as a somewhat lonely and anxious child was greatly enhanced by the mediated connections I made through print text with authors I've never met in person, but yet socialized with them via their autobiographical tales or fictional characters.  And in recent years, I have felt less isolated while in a vocational role of caring for littles at home by having the ability to make mediated connections on Facebook and Twitters with other parents and scholars who are thinking, writing and living out experiences we could share through various digitally mediated encounters in the various and asynchronous times we could have a few minutes to engage and commune as fellow humans.  I've communed with many humans I've never met and discovered more about my own emotional experience, by receiving their wisdom or experience as mediated through various film, music and theatre compositions and performances

While a few years ago I said to myself I never would want to take or teach a fully online course because of its seemingly isolating tendencies, I have had a few experiences while working through Module 1 which help me see that an online course can enrich someone's human experience by providing access into a specific discourse community of people which couldn't be easily gathered into the same room at the same time for unmediated interaction. Because our curiosity and desire to learn with and interact with people who share our interest on certain specialized topics is such a good gift, it is a very good gift to have and use some of these tools that allow us to build and strengthen a digitally mediated discourse community that enriches our discovery and rewards our search to learn important things along with others who have similar inquiry interests. 

 I hope to always have a healthy balance of unmediated physical contact with my closest family members, co-workers and friends, along with mediated stimulating contact with the people who are distant from me in time or place, but are worth finding and connecting with since they get as excited as I do about certain texts or questions or problems or inquiries or discoveries.

Comments

  1. Jessica, what a beautiful essay on the importance of physically being there. I agree that physical presence is the ideal, but when that's not possible, or feasible, how close can human beings actually be? Physically being in the same place doesn’t seem to be a critical factor for Christian community. Paul said in Col.2:5 “For though I am absent from you in body, I am present with you in spirit and delight to see how orderly you are and how firm your faith in Christ is.”

    St. Augustine echoed Paul’s position: “It is not your absence which saddens me, for we are part of that church which, however far it extends throughout the world, through God’s favor forms the one great head which is the Savior. As a result, however far apart we are even in the furthest corners of the world, yet we are together in Him in the unity of whose body we remain. How much closer together we are when we are in the same body than we would be even if we lived in the same house?” Those are some powerful words, aren't they?

    Like Paul, I know the value of face to face physical presence. But I also know how technology tools can enhance and sometimes even make possible communication and community that otherwise may not even happen at all.

    When my oldest daughter Becky went off to college, it was kind of hard, not so much for her, but for my wife and me. Fortunately we had email and then instant messaging, so we were able to keep in touch. Now I have 4 daughters, 2 sons-in-law, and 5 grandkids in Indiana, Michigan, Florida, and California. We have a Facebook group where we continually keep in touch. My daughters post pics and videos of the grandkids several times a day, and often we do live video messaging. These tools enhance our relationships.

    Of course, physical presence would be better. In the area of higher education, institutions like Trinity have to consider the market. What do students want and where are they going for education. When we find out that many are seeking online courses, shouldn't we try to meet their needs, and do it in a way that honors God and community?

    ReplyDelete
  2. As someone who greatly admires language, I read your post and went back and read it again. It is a beautiful reflection. I was particularly drawn to your thoughts about the etymology of "company." Your reflection led me to the question of what it means to share 'bread.' Bread can refer to sustenance--that which sustains or nourishes us.

    When I think of it like that, I realize how powerful a role online connections have made in my world. Many years ago I began a blog as a means to participate in an online community of teachers who wrote "slices of life" and completed an annual slice of life daily writing challenge in the month of March. I had been searching for like-minded teachers outside the four walls of my school building and happened upon the blog that began this challenge.

    More than ten years later, I have forged friendships with other teacher-bloggers across state lines (even in other countries), many of whom I have now met face to face at conferences. Ruth Ayres, who was co-founder of the blogging challenge is now a very close friend of mine. I consider her a professional and spiritual mentor; she is someone who nourishes and sustains me. Our face to face connection would not have happened if not for the sharing of words online.

    I believe it is the content of the connection that trumps the means of the connection every time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for this...we just hosted an "unplugged" day at our high school and one of our teachers posted signs on her doorway that asked students to simply be present for the day. So simple and so powerful to our students these days. On one hand, technology gives us the ability to connect to anyone, anywhere, at anytime. On the other hand, I'm reading article after article claiming people feel more lonely than ever. This is why I appreciated this first week of this class which challenged me to think about how to create a community and why it's needed.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Module 2 Reflections

Module 3, In the middle of the list

Module 4